Cary Dairy Ice Cream Cakes

We make celebrations a piece of cake.

Meet our Cake Decorator, Sandy!

Custom Cakes Available Upon Request

Have your cake and eat it, too.

We always offer a variety of cakes in stock, and can make custom cakes upon request! 

Made with Love at Cary Dairy with Super-Premium Ice Cream!

We make all of our cakes in-house! Using super-premium ice cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Co., it’s sure to be the best ice cream cake you’ve ever had. All cakes are made with rich Chocolate or Vanilla cake (Marble Cake also available for Baby Cakes),  with a thick layer of super-premium ice cream in the middle – and topped with delicious whipped icing.

Custom Cakes Available

Looking for a special cake for a special occasion? Call us at (847) 829-4623 or order it online here. Pick your ice cream flavor, cake flavor, icing, any colors or sprinkles, and any custom message!

*Please allow a 24-hour window for custom cakes. Any cake orders for pick-up Saturday or Sunday must be placed by 12pm the Thursday before. Pre-made cakes available always in-store! *

8" Ice Cream Cakes | Serves 10-14

Made with Super-Premium Ice Cream in between two layers of rich, dense cake!

Baby Cakes | Serves 2-3

Made with Super-Premium Ice Cream on top of one layer of rich, dense cake!